1.5K views
17 comments

What happened to the old spumoni ice cream, it was green, (pistacio), red (cherry) and chocolate and DELICIOUS. The last couple of times that I bought it at Publix in Florida, it was white instead of green and not very many nuts, red, but not many cherries, it wasn't very good and I hate to say this but probably won't buy it again.

You should probably stop experimenting and leave what was good--alone!

This was the only ice cream that I bought, and now I have none, thanks Edy's! I've looked into several different ice creams but can't find spumoni.

Monetary Loss: $6.

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution.

Edys Pros: Old spumoni icecream.

Edys Cons: New version of the ice cream.

Location: Holiday, Florida

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review

Comments

chat-icon

Please avoid publishing any personal information and promotional content

You will be automatically registered on our site. Username and password will be sent to you via email.
Post Comment
Guest

My Publix in Marietta, Ga. quit carrying Edy's Spumoni Ice Cream too.

I looked for it at Walmart near me as well and couldn't find it there either. Far better than the boring Neopolitan ice cream my mother bought us. I first fell in love with Spumoni ice cream at a Spaghetti Factory. I think they changed the green pistachio to white did fear of green food due so why didn't they change the cherry red to white too?

I preferred the original colours. Please return it to Publix.

Orine Wsn

I canโ€™t find Spumoni ice cream anywhere. I have lived in PA - Philly area and now in VA suburb of DC.

I have been to so many supermarkets I canโ€™t even count- Giant, Food Lion, Target, Trader Joeโ€™s, Wegmans, Whole Foods, shop rite, Aldo, Acme, McCaffreysโ€ฆnothing. No brand wants to produce it anymore.

Guest

Edy's/Dryer's/Nestle, whatever their name is, told me that it was now only available at BJ's. But if the pistachio is white, forget it.

I will stick with Talenti's Pistachio, which is pretty decent.

Publix is also screwing around and not carrying a bunch of stuff that I now have to find at other supermarkets and stores like Target. The smart Marketing ppl don't realize that once you have to go find 'stuff' at another store, you do your regular shopping at that store as well.

Guest

Edy's wrote back and said they quit making it due public demand!!!!!

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1629131

so they say the public demanded they stop making spumoni?? lol

Guest

Really irritated. I really like Edys supmoni Canโ€™t find it anywhere.

Target, Walmart all say in stock but no one has it on their shelves. Do you think the suppliers are only selling to restaurants and not to retail for consumer sales?

Guest

Been looking for Edys Spumoni ice cream. Have not seen in Publix or Walmart although found there in past years. Anyone know where to get?

Guest

I canโ€™t find the delicious Spumoni in New Jersey either. Please bring it here and make it the old way with cherries, nuts and the three: chocolate, Pistacio and cherry ice cream . Itโ€™s the best.

Guest

Eddy' Spimoni has its pistachio back, just bought two in Publix. Yay

Guest

I loved the Spumoni as well. Cant find it anymore.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-1321063

the REAL stuff had paper dividers in between slices, like real cheesecake does... a real new yorker

Guest

Edys Spumoni was my favorite. Have had trouble finding so I haven't bought for a few years.

I happened to google and saw that Target and Walmart allegedly carried and their web sites said it was in stock. Sent husband to get and was going to buy several only to be told they don't have it!

This is so irritating. Guess I won't be buying any Edys products any more.

Guest

Well it is supposed to be pistachio ice cream but they took the green color out of it and it looks vanilla

Guest

Also disappointed in the new spumoni. Will buy a different brand sold at Wegmans from now on. Too bad..Edy's used to make a real,authentic tasting spumoni

Guest

I totally agree--I don't like the new version. Please bring back the old.

Guest

Also annoyed, this isnt spumoni anymore, its neapolitan - which Edy's puts out already! Bring back the Pistachio!

Guest

I agree 100%!! Our family would buy one or more Edy's Spumoni every week.

Until I see the pistachio return to the previous fabulous flavor and fruit and nuts back, we will no longer buy it. So very, very disappointed in your brand.

Edys Reviews

  1. 43 reviews
  2. 12 reviews
  3. 26 reviews
  4. 13 reviews
  5. 19 reviews
Edys reviews